Buffalo Board of Education Dysfunction – by Carl Paladino

To:  The Buffalo Superintendent of Schools and The Buffalo Board of Education

From:  Carl P. Paladino
Re:  Dysfunction

The following is the first of a series of papers outlining to the Superintendent and the BOE that its administration of the school district is lacking even in the simplest of responsibilities.

The district has a serious attendance and truancy problem.

The first step is usually to acknowledge to the community that the problem exists and has existed for a long time and other attempts by the administration to rectify the problem, if any, have failed.

You don’t like doing that because you think it makes you look incompetent. You are ashamed to admit that you don’t know how to resolve the problem and problems of this nature have historically been handled simply by looking the other way until critics stop concerning themselves with the issues.

The analyses of Mike Madigan, submitted below, clearly defines your problem in dealing with school district challenges.  You decided to simply alter statistics to reflect that the problem no longer exists.  You changed the protocol for collecting the information to a presumption that the student is present unless the teacher specifically marks the student absent.

This is like setting up the standardized English and math tests to default so that each student scores 100% unless otherwise indicated by the teachers.

You actually held a ceremony at a televised BOE meeting to hand out awards and trophies to principals of schools that have, on paper, shown improvement regardless of being based on faulty counts.  Was that to boost the morale of the principals or to show that joining in a lie makes everyone involved feel good?

You glossed over a major problem that attacks the heart of the district failure, wrapped it up nicely with a bow, and put it up on the shelf with all the other bothersome challenges your incompetent BOE does not want to face.

Just more examples of BOE brilliance and genius. You just can’t make this stuff up.


Critical Questions Raised Regarding BPS Attendance Data Accuracy

By: Mike Madigan

Elliott Report link: http://www.p12.nysed.gov/accountability/de/documents/BuffaloDE-1stQtrlyActionStatusReport.pdf

In September a new attendance tracking system was put in place as part of the “Infinite Campus” program in the Buffalo Public Schools (BPS). The Distinguished Educator Report released 15-March-2013 on page 6 suggests a possible critical defect may exist with BPS’s usage of this program. As per Elliott, this program was created to report that all students are in attendance as a default value prior to attendance being taken. It would be expected that a null value of “attendance not taken” would be reported if a teacher failed to report rather than reporting that a class has 100% in attendance. If the system accepts this default data as valid the data could be erroneous and shouldn’t be used for performance reports or decision making.

If as Elliott indicated this system reports that all students are in attendance as a default, and if the system accepts that data, when a teacher fails to report attendance, the potential impact is:

  • 100% attendance being reported for that class for that day even though historical data suggests most classes have absences daily resulting in the reports being corrupted.
  • For the teacher who did not comply with reporting requirements the consequence would be improved attendance based on faulty counts. The teacher’s class attendance record could result in improved attendance evaluation ratings and bad behavior positively incentivized.
  • By the Principles and Administrators failing to take valid attendance, teachers would ‘improve’ attendance for that school and for the district (A positive incentive to not audit and to permit non-compliance).
  • For the Superintendent in charge of the district attendance results will be reported falsely high. Potential and inaccurate claims of improvement may be made.

Answers to the following questions would help determine if the Elliott observation invalidates  BPS attendance reporting:

  • Does the system accept default 100% attendance values as reportable data? Why would data generated from such a system be deemed valid, integral and worthy of reporting?
  • Is there a system Administrator at each school that verifies all teachers have reported attendance? What action is taken to ensure 100% compliance with reporting requirements?
  • Is there electronic signature with time and date stamps that documents if attendance is taken?
  • Is there an audit trail with date time stamp and electronic signature documenting/retaining all prior edited versions to prevent retroactive revisions/data adjustments?
  • Is there a requirement to justify retroactive changes and is electronic signature required to approve and ensure edits are done beyond a certain time range?
  • Are there classroom spot checks and verification of accuracy?
  • Why would this system be set to 100% attendance rather than a null value that would notify the teacher and Principles of failures to report?
  • Is there a policy in place regarding compliance with daily attendance reporting requirements?
  • What are consequences for failure to report accurate attendance?

About TEANewYork

TEANewYork was established as a resource for many things political, issue-oriented and policy-wise, and for things you can actually do, to actively participate in reforming our severely dysfunctional New York State government. What are you waiting for? Jump on in!
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Buffalo Board of Education Dysfunction – by Carl Paladino

  1. hank reardon says:

    Your efforts are misguided and will be a continous failure. You both miss the crux of the problem completely. The problem is with your faulty ideology. You continue to fight the “system” within the framework of that system. The game is rigged. You can’t win. Your time and efforts are wasted with all of these “distractions”. The problems you all continue to focus on are just the symptoms of the disease. Until you address the source of the problem, you will continue to be trampled under foot. The problem is simple: EDUCATION SHOULD NOT BE COMPULSORY NOR REGULATED BY GOVERNMENT. Plain and simple. You all support freedom, but fail to see that the education system was hijacked by socialists back in the late 1800’s and early 1900’s. You either don’t know your history, don’t care to address it or just don’t get it. Study Teddy Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson specifically. They were “progressives” and absolute socialists. The problem isn’t attendence, grades, funding, etc. The problem is loss of freedom. Address THAT. Who cares about all of the other nonsense, ALL of these problems are the RESULT of the REAL PROBLEM. Your efforts should be on exposing the fact that your corrupt criminal government has taken over the education system! It is there, and in the halls of universities that they for generations now are churning out the socialist, collectivist agenda that is tearing this country apart. They poison your childrens heads with collectivist ideology at every turn. It’s what they are and what they are not teaching that is the root of the issue. THEY determine the curriculum, THEY determine the delivery, THEY are pushing the ideology, THEY CONTROL THE MINDS OF YOUR CHILDREN AND THE FUTURE. “What is the best way to defeat your enemy? Teach their children.” -Sun Tzu. Your approch is as ridiculous here as to your 2nd ammendment approach. Where are you going with all of this? Really? The machine is BIG and you will be crushed by it. Until people realize that until the INDIVIDUAL changes, NOTHING WILL CHANGE. You keep approching problem solving with the same consciousness that got us into this mess. Use your time, energy and wisdom to teach. If you keep fighting the machine, you will lose. Walk away from it. Until people change nothing changes. This is what America has become. The gov’t is a reflection of the morality of a society. The truth and answers are out there. I want you to think about this as you grow angry at this post. You will have to come to the fact that I am right. Open yourselves to the truth. Direct the right message, a message based on facts, rational thought, and logic. Stop promoting solutions and ideas based on feelings, emotion, personal beliefs and faith. None of these things are rooted in reality. They can’t be used to prove or solve anything. That is why you fail. – The Voice of Reaon.

  2. TEANewYork says:

    Can I just call you Marty? So Marty, how do you propose we address the source of the problem, that education has been hijacked by government? I would suggest we get it into the hands of private individuals like the successful charter school model, and offer incentives for private and home schooling. And for those forced into a failing system, expose the corruption you talk about, unseat those who are responsible for the failure and change the failure to success. That’s exactly what Carl P is doing.

    To suggest we don’t know history because we are forced to work within the existing system is naive at best. Complaining about problems without offering solutions is spitting into the wind, Marty. Put up or shut up…with all due respect, of course.

  3. Our Country was founded on feelings,emotions,personal beliefs and faith.Seems the “Voice of reason” makes no sense.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s